Casey Moore's Oyster House
About this place
Casey Moore's Oyster House occupies a house that was built in 1910 and lived in for decades by William and Mary Moeur, who were prominent in early Tempe. The home was renovated and turned into a restaurant in 1973, sold again in 1986 and has been Casey Moore's ever since. It stands at 850 S Ash Avenue, less than a mile from Arizona State University's Tempe campus.
A haunted reputation
Ghost stories go back decades here. According to the restaurant's lore, William and Mary have both been seen, sometimes dancing in the upstairs bedroom. Whether or not you believe it, the old house gives the stories a natural setting.
What to eat and drink
Despite the name, the menu is broad: hot wings, steaming French onion soup, salads, sandwiches, pasta and entrées. Oysters are the namesake, with oyster shooters, fried oysters by the half dozen or dozen and Oysters Rockefeller, and the menu also lists crab cakes, fish and chips and tacos. The French onion soup is a favorite of regulars.
Patio and happy hour
The patio is where many people end up, for socializing, lawn games and a drink. Happy hour runs 3 to 7 PM Monday through Friday and 11 AM to 4 PM on weekends.
Common Questions
When was the building constructed?
1910, as a home for William and Mary Moeur.
When did it become a restaurant?
It was converted in 1973 and has been Casey Moore's since 1986.
Is it really haunted?
The restaurant has ghost stories that go back decades, centered on its original owners.
What are the happy hour times?
3 to 7 PM Monday through Friday, and 11 AM to 4 PM on Saturday and Sunday.
How can I check dining hours?
Call (480) 968-9935.
Details last reviewed October 8, 2026. Hours and menus change, so call before you go. How we check our listings.
Photos
Menu
Appetizers
-
Casey's Chicken Wings Full dozen $18, half dozen $10, multiple sauces18.00 $
-
Southwest Potato Skins Homemade skins with green chilies, cheese, bacon and jalapeños12.00 $
-
Potato Tacos Two crispy tortillas filled with mashed potatoes and toppings7.00 $
-
Chicken Fingers Beer battered or breaded, with fries and ranch16.00 $
-
Mozzarella Sticks Lightly battered, with marinara10.00 $
-
Fried Pickles Lightly battered spears with ranch10.00 $
-
Calamari Rings Golden fried with cocktail sauce16.00 $
-
Chipotle Hummus Homemade spicy chipotle hummus with warm pitas10.00 $
-
Escargot Snails and mushroom caps with scampi butter and garlic toast17.00 $
Oysters
-
Raw Oysters on Half Shell Fresh East Coast Blue Point oysters shucked to order (half dozen $19)30.00 $
-
Oysters Rockefeller Topped with spinach and bacon, baked in mornay sauce (half dozen $24)36.00 $
-
Combo Plate Three oysters and three cocktail shrimp18.00 $
-
Oyster Shooter Oyster with cocktail sauce, horseradish and pepper vodka10.00 $
Fish & Seafood
-
Jumbo Chilled Shrimp Cocktail With horseradish and cocktail sauce28.00 $
-
Casey's Fish & Chips Northern Atlantic cod filet, beer battered19.00 $
-
Casey's Fried Shrimp & Chips Fresh shrimp in light beer batter28.00 $
-
Steamed Clams Creamy, buttery garlic broth with garlic toast20.00 $
-
Crab Cakes Three cakes with real crabmeat and chipotle mayo17.00 $
Soups
-
Clam Chowder Homemade, served with crackers (cup $6)8.00 $
-
French Onion Au Gratin Homemade, with bread crouton and melted cheese (cup $6)8.00 $
Salads
-
Shrimp and Avocado Salad Mixed greens with chilled shrimp, avocado, egg and cheese19.00 $
-
Caesar Salad Romaine tossed in homemade Caesar dressing11.00 $
Ratings & Reviews
Based on 4,113 guest ratings.
Add a Review
Thank you! Your review has been submitted for moderation.
Location
Other places to try
- Three Bear's Cafe 1824 AZ-260, Heber, AZ 85928
- Bisbee's Table Copper Queen Plaza, 2 Main St, Bisbee, AZ 85603
- Yosemite Falls Café - Shaw 1455 Shaw Ave, Clovis, CA 93611
- Bread & Butter Cafe 4231 E 22nd St, Tucson, AZ 85711
- Avocado's Grill 200 N 23rd St, Paragould, AR 72450
- Café Roma 101 S Main St, Enterprise, AL 36330